Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children by Random Riggs
Navid Tajkhorshid
Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children by Ransom Riggs is a story about the effects and consequences of a group of remarkable, or peculiar, people on the rest of the world. It follows 16-year-old Jacob Portman, in his journey to understand his grandfather’s mysterious death, leading him do discover some more uncomfortable and terrifying truths that he may not want to know. I would recommend this story to anyone looking for a light read, but I do believe it has some pacing and tonal issues, specifically in the beginning and middle chapters of the book.
The story starts with a prologue of Jacob’s grandfather telling him stories about a special home he was at during the second world war. He had many pictures of children and teenagers doing seemingly impossible things, such as levitating. His grandfather had also mentioned monsters that he fought in the war, and when Jacob grew up, he simply assumed that the monsters were Nazis and the magical children were tales to entertain him as a kid. However, when Jacob’s grandfather starts to become seemingly delusional, he tries to convince Jacob of these stories again. Jacob dies not believe him until when his grandfather dies to one of these monsters in the forest, which only Jacob was able to catch sight of. The only clues Jacob has as to what these monsters are are a few cryptic messages his grandfather had left for him. These messages eventually lead him to a low population remote island far off the coast of the U.K. On this island, Jacob discovers a secret society of gifted, or peculiar, children who have unique powers, the children that his grandfather would tell him stories about. He starts to befriend some of these children, and almost gets entirely accepted into their society, after a less than warm welcome.
Jacob as a character is likable as a main protagonist. He can be blunt, but is considerate, is not very social, but polite, and can be unknowingly rude, but strives to be respectful. His characterization, apart from the first three chapters, is consistent. It is possible to get to know him entirely from his narration alone, since there is a much more distinct voice in this novel than many others that I have read. I can easily see myself in Jacob, which is not to say that we are similar, but that his decisions and flaws are very human. Over the story, he evolves to become a more well-rounded person, mostly in terms of his ability to socialize. Through his interactions with the peculiar children, he learns what is feels like to be in a family, as his real family is nearly always busy.
However, I do believe that there is some tonal dissonance between the first few chapters and the rest of the book. Jacob seems very different than he does in the other chapters. He seems extremely nonchalant and rude. This could be interpretedas a starting point for character development, but unlike in the later chapters, where Jacob slowly becomes more social and caring, this change happens as soon as he gets to the island. This makes the reader’s first impressions of him very different than the character they will spend time with for most of the book.
The novel is also filled with exposition throughout this entire story. New facts about peculiar children come up all the time. For example, Jacob learns what the monsters are just before the final three chapters. This is not a huge problem, as the book is the start of a series, but the exposition is so closely related to the plot of the book that it can become annoying to try to understand the story until the end. This is not a huge problem, especially snce this book is the start of a series, but it was off-putting at times to hear another lecture from a the mentor character about the one other thing that they decided to withhold from Jacob.
Great review! I read this book a while ago and I had a lot of the same problems you did, especially with the pacing (I found it really hard to get through the book) and the exposition. I liked your description of Jacob as a character- he does seem like a real person most of the time. I'd like to see your thoughts on the supernatural elements of the story because they're really important and also kind of strange.
ReplyDeleteEven though this entire review was well written, there were two moments in particular that stuck out. I really liked your line “...after a less than warm welcome” as it conveys a lot of information in a short amount of words. Even if it’s not a huge detail, this quote spurs the readers to interest without the typical “this book is good, read it.”I also liked that you said there is not much deeper meaning as neither a positive or a negative. The stereotype is that a good book should be deep, thought-provoking, or meaningful, but I agree that when reading for pleasure, those elements aren’t necessarily positives. This was an overall good review, and I was impressed by the way you balance an unbiased summary with your own opinions.
ReplyDeleteI appreciate your blunt and honest assessment of the characters and plot. I too, share your dislike for plots that either develop too quickly or slowly. From your review, I could tell you thought the plot was too drawn out during non action parts of the book, and too fast paced during the parts that deserved more attention. Overall, really nice review.
ReplyDelete